h1

Muslims stealing from Jews raised few eyebrows

June 16, 2011

The Islamists and international Left have long protested the “theft” of land by Israel from the Arabs of the Palestinian territories.  However, they have been utterly silent on the property that Arab nations stole from the Jews that they kicked out of Iraq, Yemen, Egypt, Syria, etc., during the 20th Century.  Here’s the rundown from YNet back on May 15 (h/t EoZ):

‘A Jew shouldn’t control Muslims’

The Jews’ situation began deteriorating with the Arab national awakening, before the State of Israel’s establishment. “From a British mandate, Iraq turned into an autonomic state in 1932 and immediately began disinheriting the Jews,” says Yehuda.

“They weren’t accepted to schools and universities and were dismissed from jobs with all sorts of claims.”

Who led the restrictions?

“The Arab nationalists and the militant Muslims. The establishment was not happy with the situation but was dragged into it, and most of the population was ambivalent: In day-to-day life they had friendly relations with the Jews, but when a Jew was appointed as a judge or government worker it bothered them, because according to their perception, a Jew is not supposed to control Muslims.”

Upon the establishment of the State of Israel, the Arab world was flooded with violent riots, massacres and plunder against the Jews. Some of the Arab governments defended the Jews, while others – mainly in Iraq and Yemen – inflamed the riots and looting.

“The Iraqi government confiscated property, as if to compensate the Palestinian refugees,” says Yehuda. “Government workers would arrive at a business and ask the Jewish owner how much he would like to ‘donate’ to the refugees. If he wouldn’t – that was the end of the business. Most of the property reached people with ties to the government.”

In 1951, the Iraqi government quietly agreed to let Jews immigrate to Israel, and almost all of them did. At the same time, it enacted a law stating that the entire Jewish property – houses, factories, goods, jewelry and bank accounts – would be nationalized.

Egyptian leader Gamal Abdel Nasser enacted similar laws after the Lavon Affair and the Sinai war. Libya’s Jews were expelled and their property was nationalized in the 1960s. “(Libya leader Muammar) Gaddafi promised to return everything within 30 years,” notes Hajaj, “but at the moment he’s busy with other stuff.”

Syria, Tunisia and Algeria did not nationalize property, but the Jews fled those countries when they gained independence (1946, 1959 and 1962, respectively), and the Muslims looted the remaining property. That is what happened to the property of Yemeni Jews who made aliyah in Operation Magic Carpet as well.

“Some of Morocco’s Jews ‘got off easy’: They immigrated with the money and property and ‘only’ left the homes,” says Hajaj. “Jews from other countries immigrated with nothing but the clothes they were wearing. My father was one of Libya’s biggest billionaires and immigrated with a suitcase weighing 20 kilos.”

$4 or 200 billion?

Researchers and organizations are at odds over the scope of the lost property.

Economist Sidney Zabludoff, a former American government worker, estimated that the property totaled some $700 million in the 1950s and reached some $6 billion in 2007. The Pensioner Affairs Ministry puts the sum at about 2 billion pounds. One organization says $30 billion and another says $100 billion in Iraq alone.

Will the Jews be compensated for the looted property? And can it, and should it, be deducted from the property Israel took from the Palestinians?

The scope of the Palestinian property is also a matter of controversy. Economist John Barncastle evaluated the Palestinian property the 1950s at some $450 million. Zabludoff said it stood at some $4 billion today. The Camp David peace talks discussed $20 billion, while Arab organizations spoke of some $200 billion.

The disagreement stems from the reevaluation method. The number of people who escaped on both sides was similar: About 730,000 Palestinians and about 700,000 Jews (excluding those who immigrated to France). Most of them lived in their own homes.

The Jews, in general, were much richer and possessed many assets in addition to the houses. But real estate is the main thing, and it is customary to add to the original value the rising prices in the places the refugees lived in. Israeli housing prices, as we all know, have gone up much more.

Israel earned a lot from the Jewish property looted in Europe and used the funds to help Holocaust survivors, although insufficiently. But until recently, the State ignored the Jewish property in Arab countries.

“Until recently, there was a lot of fear,” says Yehuda. “During the peace talks, Egypt’s Jews demanded that (then-Israeli Prime Minister) Menachem Begin include a clause requiring compensation, but he wouldn’t listen. I think the government was afraid that it would have to pay the Palestinians more.

“They changed their mind when (former US President) Bill Clinton stated that an international fund would be established to compensate both sides. Since then, they are hoping that the arrangement won’t be at their expense.”

The property in Israel is worth more thanks to the Jews’ knowledge and capital. Why should it increase the compensation to the Palestinians?…

About these ads

One comment

  1. on political level Muslim absorbed Hiter Mein kampf even before it became mandatory in German house holds… the Urdu version of Mein kampf (translated by a Muslim from British India ) was a best seller in Asia even back in 1928…

    and in 1932, the arabs had same that Germany had observed under Nazis during 1935 onwards till 1944 is something new even for me…

    sicking is that these peoples are seen as victims, rather then supremacist till today… even-though again and again they show their supremacist signs… around 1999, they forced non-muslims in Afghanistan to wear arm bands… again it was ignored by our global Media… unfortunately :(



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 5,083 other followers

%d bloggers like this: